Catastrophic Theology

Christians called to observe anti-Israel Nakba Day.

For Christians to join in the delegitimization of Israel does tremendous damage to our witness to the Jewish people.
For Christians to join in the delegitimization of Israel does tremendous damage to our witness to the Jewish people. Photo: Roni Schutzer/Flash90

CAPE TOWN, November 8th 2022 – Hostility to Israel has taken on yet another ugly form, this time from so-called Christians I’m sorry to say.

The Anglican Church of Southern Africa’s top decision-making body has passed a series of anti-Israel resolutions, including the call on members to observe Nakba (Catastrophe) Day, which is effectively to believe that Israel has no right to be a nation.

Nakba is the name applied by Palestinians to the Jewish state’s annual Independence Day, and is normally marked by protests, sometimes violent.

The approval by Anglicans of such behaviour is diabolical to say the least, a direct challenge to God’s promises, and an extraordinary irony on several counts as they allow themselves to be used as a mouthpiece of the ‘father of lies’ (John 8:44).

First of all, it flies in the face of the Abraham peace accords through which former enemies of Israel have extended the hand of friendship.

It also goes against the grain of the burgeoning movement of reconciliation between Jews and Arabs who follow Jesus (most Messianic congregations in Israel are mixed).

Thirdly, the apartheid regime was eventually defeated thanks in great measure to South Africa’s leading Jews, such as industrialist Harry Oppenheimer and the courageous MP Helen Suzman.

And yet clerics and politicians from that part of the world now have the gall to accuse Israel of practicing this form of discrimination which, apart from being a shocking lie, is a gross insult to those who suffered most from apartheid.

Yet another irony was the involvement of South Africans in the founding of the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem in 1980 to signal support for the Jewish people by recognising their eternal capital – support mostly lacking from the rest of the nations with the honourable exception of President Trump. And now it seems that Britain is backing down from earlier indications that they were prepared to move their embassy to where it rightfully belongs.

Another irony is that Anglicans in England earlier this year held a service of repentance in Oxford Cathedral for historic antisemitism perpetrated by Christians.

I fear that those behind the South African resolutions, and other ‘Christians’ who think this way, are not worshipping the God of our Lord Jesus Christ who is, after all, the God of Israel.

Tragically, it affects our witness to the Jewish people who thus become more convinced that an antisemitic Jesus could not possibly be their Messiah.

As a Cape Town-based missionary with an Anglican society put it:

“To regard the founding of any nation as a catastrophe is ungodly to say the least, but this kind of thing conveys a distorted picture of Jesus to the Jewish community which makes witnessing much harder.”

A Haifa-based pastor has credited Christians who love Israel as responsible for bringing his family into a relationship with the Saviour. This is also the likely effect of the many thousands of Christians from around the world who attend the annual Feast of Tabernacles in Jerusalem to indicate their love and support for the nation.

Commenting on the response to their ‘march’ of witness from Israelis lining the route, one of those who went this year said:

“I’ve never felt such joy and received so much love from Israelis.”

Another described it as “a wonderful rehearsal for the millennial age” (see Zechariah 14:16).

But we should be slow to point a finger at Anglican failings at the southern tip of Africa. For much of the Western church has effectively been saying the same thing for years – that modern Israel is unrelated to biblical Israel; that the Jewish nation making such an impact on today’s world is somehow an aberration and not part of God’s plan.

All of which is a travesty of the truth. Much of this ‘theology’ emanates from the unscriptural teaching that the Church has replaced Israel in God’s purposes.

We should hang our heads in shame for entertaining such ideas, and repent while we can. The Bible is sprinkled with hundreds of references to Jewish restoration – both to the land (called ‘making aliyah’) and the Lord.

Here is just one example from Jeremiah, speaking for the Lord:

“See, I will bring them (Israel) from the land of the north and gather them from the ends of the earth.” (Jeremiah 31:8)

And he goes on to announce God’s promise of a new covenant with the people of Israel (verse 31). Did you notice that? Not “with the Church” but “with the people of Israel,” though of course Gentiles are, by grace, able to share in that covenant.

Later in the same chapter, the Lord promises that as long as the sun shines by day and the moon and stars by night, Israel will never cease to be a nation before him (verses 35-37).

I agree with American pastor Lou Engle, who I understand has called for the Church to make ‘spiritual aliyah’ – by which he means returning to the Jewish roots of our faith. That’s my prayer too.

For unless we identify with the Jewish people, from whom we have been blessed both with the Scriptures and our Messiah, and take every opportunity of showing them love and concern amidst rising antisemitism, how can we expect them to respond positively to our message?

As Isaiah put it, “How beautiful on the mountains are the feet of those who bring good news…who say to Zion, ‘Your God reigns!’” (Isaiah 52:7)



Charles Gardner is author of Israel the Chosen, available from Amazon; Peace in Jerusalem, available from; To the Jew FirstA Nation Reborn, and King of the Jews, all available from Christian Publications International.



Israel Today Membership

Read all member content. Access exclusive, in-depth reports from Israel! Free Zoom events. Connect with Israel right from your home! Raise a voice of truth and hope. Support Faith-based journalism in Jerusalem!


/ month
Full access to Israel Today's Member-only content on all Digital Platforms.
Become a Member


/ year
Full access to Israel Today's Member-only content on all Digital Platforms.
Save 18% Per Month.
Become a Member

Six Months

every 6 months
Full access to Israel Today's Member-only content on all Digital Platforms.
Save 9% Per Month.
Become a Member

2 responses to “Catastrophic Theology”

  1. Disciple 1978 says:

    I don’t think it’s just about helping the church witness to Israel, it’s more about Israel realising who she is.

    The church has had Messiah Yeshua for ages yet has only had partial success in creating a Christian world. The Roman emperor realised the power of Christ to turn the world upside down (Acts 17:6) and compromised the church to make that a reality for the Roman religion. Christian paganism went global, all nations now know how to celebrate Christmas and Easter.

    The Jews always knew that Christianity got it wrong. The corrupt priesthood, indulgent kings and impoverished people was so far removed from a realm of justice, truth and mercy (Micah 6:8; Psalm 89:14) that there was nothing to desire about it.

    Israel’s hold on Torah has kept them from most of the world’s corruption. However, they haven’t had the power to conquer other cultures. Messiah wants them to do just that, but only in His way. When Judaism embraces Messiah Yeshua it will be life from the dead for the world (Rom 11:15) and even Christianity will have to stand up and take notice.

  2. Mark Cooley says:

    You pronounced them correct So Called Christians: Matthew 7:21-23 GOD gave The Children of Israel Their Land Forever. JESUS will Return & Reign from There One Day Soon …Maranatha….

Leave a Reply

Israel Today Newsletter

Daily news

FREE to your inbox

Israel Heute Newsletter

Tägliche Nachrichten

KOSTENLOS in Ihrer Inbox

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter