all

all

MembersConscription: A debate about peace, or survival?

Why Israel and Germany are talking about the same question – but facing completely different realities.

Ultra-Orthodox Jews clash with police as they protest the conscription of ultra-Orthodox Jews into the Israeli army in Bnei Brak. Photo by Erik Marmor/Flash90.
Ultra-Orthodox Jews clash with police as they protest the conscription of ultra-Orthodox Jews into the Israeli army in Bnei Brak. Photo by Erik Marmor/Flash90.

In recent days, I have repeatedly engaged with the school strikes by German youth against a possible reintroduction of military conscription in Germany. From an Israeli perspective, this phenomenon initially seems alien. But you know what? We too have a group that, in its own way, is carrying out a similar kind of strike against military service: the ultra-orthodox yeshiva and Torah students. For religious reasons, they refuse service in the army while their brothers from the same people are at war. On the instructions of their rabbis, they are protesting against the planned law that would end this special exemption and also include orthodox students in national conscription. On their placards one reads slogans such as: “We would rather die than be drafted”; “Better that Hamas kills me than that I become secular”; “We do not believe in the rule of the unbelievers, and we will not appear in their offices”; “Better to die as an ultra-orthodox than to report for military service as a secular Israeli”; and even “Stalin is here”

Israel Today Membership

Become a Member

  • Read all member content

    Get exclusive in-depth reports from Israel.

  • Get exclusive in-depth reports from Israel

    Connect with Israel, right from your home.

  • Lift up the voice of truth and hope

    Support Jerusalem-based Zionist journalism.

Already a member? .

About the author

Patrick Callahan

This is an example of author bio/description. Beard fashion axe trust fund, post-ironic listicle scenester. Uniquely mesh maintainable users rather than plug-and-play testing procedures.

One response to “Conscription: A debate about peace, or survival?”

  1. Franciscus says:

    The Orthodox view that being drafted into the IDF will make them secular. Over the last few years it seems that the IDF has the opposite effect, the Secular will soon refuse to serve because of the danger of becoming ‘religious’ !

Leave a Reply

Login

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.