(JNS) Most wars throughout history have begun and ended symbolically.
Before the State of Israel and a Palestinian Arab identity were established, the first violence in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict was the 1920 Jerusalem riots that saw the murder of five Jews and 216 injured. It was the result of a symbol.
The carnage was set off by Mufti Hajj Amin al-Husseini, who saw the Temple Mount as the symbol of pan-Arab, pan-Muslim nationalism, with himself as its guardian. The Mufti’s incendiary rhetoric ensured that much Jewish and Arab blood would be shed during his lifetime and in the decades since.
See: Jerusalem Mufti’s Personal Diary Revealed in New Book
For over 100 years, the Arabs have coopted the Temple Mount, a site that was largely ignored for centuries by Muslims, as their rallying call and symbolic “ground zero” for the Israeli-Arab conflict.
For Israel, however, the Temple Mount was where defeat was snatched from the jaws of victory.
In 1967, Israel recorded one of the most stunning victories of modern history by beating back several Arab armies, increasing its size many times and liberating its historic, indigenous and ancestral heartland in Judea and Samaria. However, it was in Jerusalem that victory could have been symbolically assured.
By putting enormous resources into redeeming the ancient Jewish capital city, Israel demonstrated a firm commitment to the symbolic over the strategic. This came to a head when a young Israeli officer, Ezra Orni, placed an Israeli flag on top of the Dome of the Rock.
As in most wars throughout history, the placing of a flag signifies victory and shows the vanquished that they have been defeated. The territory underneath the flag is now under the control of the victors.
Nevertheless, when then-Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Dayan saw the flag through his binoculars, he immediately ordered it taken down because, he claimed, it would set the whole Middle East on fire.
Israel’s decision to take down the flag and turn over administration of the Temple Mount to the Islamic Waqf was arguably the moment when the defeated gained a glimmer of hope that all was not lost. They saw that despite the Jews’ heroic victory and the absolute decimation of the Arab armies, the Jews still feared their enemies.
This glimmer of hope has only increased over the years as Israeli acquiescence to Arab and Muslim demands on the Temple Mount has grown.
The Arabs see Israeli policemen drag Jews off the Temple Mount for saying a few quiet words of prayer, the Waqf decide that Jews cannot drink from public water fountains, non-Muslims forced to wear a yellow mark on their clothing symbolic of dhimmi humiliation and that any type of rioting brings Israeli decision-makers to heel.
In short, the so-called status quo on the Temple Mount has been weaponized to gain Palestinian victories and Israeli concessions.
When new Israeli National Security Minister Itamar Ben-Gvir ascended the Mount for 12 minutes shortly after assuming office, as some of his predecessors had done, the appropriation of this non-event for symbolic purposes by Palestinian leaders and the apologetics of Israeli decision-makers and opinion-shapers were sadly predictable.
Once again, we heard from numerous Israeli talking heads that such actions would inflame the Middle East. Ben-Gvir’s visit was condemned by hypocrites in the international community who call for the continuation of the status quo and then attack Israel and Jews for adhering to it.
However, Ben-Gvir’s ascension was a powerful moment that might allow Israel to regain momentum in its century-long war against Palestinian violence and rejectionism.
To the Arabs, the Temple Mount is where this war began. For a senior Israeli minister to defy their threats is an important symbolic victory.
For too long, Israeli politicians have followed Dayan’s lead. They have compromised and conceded in the face of threats real or imaginary.
We will never know if the conflict could have ended with the symbolic and permanent raising of the Israeli flag on the Temple Mount in 1967. We do know that, despite the overwhelming military victory, the conflict was not conceded by Israel’s enemies.
Perhaps Israel can start pushing back against what the Palestinian rejectionists see as growing Jewish humiliation and Israeli capitulation. It can do so by reasserting its sovereignty over the Temple Mount, a site won but not fully liberated.
I hope that more Israeli leaders, religious and secular, left and right, will understand the symbolism of the Temple Mount and ascend. They can adhere to the status quo, but not to threats of violence.
These simple yet important acts could send a strong and determined message to those who seek a future without Jewish sovereignty that we will not be removed.
Saudi Journalist Visits Israel, Implies Riyadh Wants Role in Jerusalem Holy Sites
Jews Arrested for Waving Israeli Flags on Temple Mount
Israelis seeking to sacrifice lamb on Temple Mount arrested
Do the Jews Have Sovereignty in Jerusalem?
Jews Told Not to Bow Heads on Temple Mount
“We Are the Owners of Jerusalem and the Entire Land of Israel!”
Third Temple is Only Cure for Coronavirus, Says Israeli Rabbi
IN PHOTOS: Temple Mount as a Battleground
Have the Jews Started Building the Third Temple?
Muslims Warn Netanyahu Against Jewish Prayer on Temple Mount
Palestinians Plotting Temple Mount Violence on Upcoming Jewish Holidays
Three Palestinians arrested for harassing Jews atop Temple Mount
Judaism Deserves As Much Respect As Islam
ANALYSIS: Coordinated Attempt to Drag Israel Into War Fails
In First Since 1967: Israelis Enter Temple Mount Through Gate of the Tribes
The Pilgrims Way: A Live Tour “Up To” Jerusalem’s Temple
The Pursuit of Kindness
US Congressman Upset That Jews Can’t Pray on Temple Mount
Eye of the Storm: Violence Atop Jerusalem’s Temple Mount
Jerusalem or Kabul? Jihadists Squabble Over Islam’s ‘Third Holiest Site’
It’s Time for a New ‘Status Quo’ on the Temple Mount
The Battle for the Temple Mount
Exposed! Is Jordan Financing the Coming Temple Mount War?
100 Years of the Temple Mount as a Tool of Muslim Propaganda
What is the Temple Mount ‘Status Quo’?
Jerusalem and the War Between Two Kingdoms
You Won’t Believe Why This Jew Was Arrested on the Temple Mount
Exclusive: “Third World War Could Erupt From Temple Mount,” Warns Jerusalem Expert
Jewish Youth Pray at Temple Mount, and Judge Rules in Their Favor
Gaza, Temple Mount and the Passover Lamb: A Story of Holiday Conflict
The Temple Mount in the Eyes of Jews, Christians and Muslims
Arab Arrested After Attacking Jewish Visitor on Temple Mount
Jews Arrested for Blowing Shofar Outside Temple Mount
When a Muslim and a Catholic Decide the Fate of Judaism’s Holiest Site
Let My People Pray
Islamic Trust Truck Caught Dumping Garbage Inside Temple Mount
The Temple Mount is Important to Christians, Too!
“The Time Has Come”: Jews Arrested En Route to Temple Mount Sacrifice
Flashpoint Temple Mount: Do We Lack Common Sense?
Sloughing Lies Off Jerusalem
Half-Million People Visited Jerusalem’s Western Wall Despite Tensions
Israel Vlog: Praying at the Western Wall
Jordanian Control of the Temple Mount Will Destroy the ‘Status Quo’
Jewish Visits to Temple Mount Break Modern Record, Expose Religious Divide
Muslims Attack Jews Praying at Western Wall
A Tragic Israeli Surrender
The Curious Voice of Sheikh Omer Salem
Likud Knesset Member’s Plan Spotlights Discrimination on Temple Mount
Palestinians Arrested for Waving Hamas Flags on Temple Mount
Walk Like an Israeli
UN again denies Jewish connection to the Temple Mount
Jews Want Sovereignty, Prayer at Temple Mount
Of Course It’s All Our Fault
Why Does Israel Storm the Al Aqsa Mosque?
Haredi coalition partner: Close Temple Mount to Jews
Muslims Fire Missile at Israel After Jew Visits Temple Mount
Ezekiel’s Temple – Metaphorical or Concrete? (Part 2)
Israel’s UN Envoy Mocks Meeting Over Ben-Gvir’s ‘Uneventful’ Temple Mount Visit
50,000: New Annual Record Set in Jewish Visits to Temple Mount
Orthodox Jews Squabble Over Temple Mount Ahead of Possible Elections
Judge Confirms: It’s Not Illegal for Jews to Pray on the Temple Mount
Without Unity, No Jerusalem
As Jews Ascend the Mountain of the LORD, Allah’s Rockets Fly
The Temple Mount, Ben-Gvir and World War III
Ezekiel’s Temple – Metaphorical or Concrete? (Part 1)
‘Jihad Tourism’ on the Rise at Temple Mount
Does the Whole World Reject National Jewish Worship?
Tachles With Aviel – Ben Gvir Is a Convenient Excuse
The Proof – of the World’s Antisemitism – Is in the Praying
Jerusalem Can’t Thrive Without Its Heart
Israel ‘Surrenders’ Temple Mount After Reported Pressure From Biden
We Must Always Remember the Extraordinary Gift of Israel
Declaration of War: Israel Considers Altering Temple Mount ‘Status Quo’
Did Netanyahu Make Secret Temple Mount Deal?
“The Time Has Come to Sacrifice the Passover Lamb on the Temple Mount!”
Israel Stops Busloads of Muslims From Reaching Temple Mount
Undeterred Jewish Groups Ascend Temple Mount Amid Passover Violence
Israel Bars Terror-Praising Muslim Cleric From Temple Mount
Peace with the Saudis is easy – they just want the Temple Mount
Who Set Fire to the Temple Mount Mosque – a Jew or a Christian?
Will the Temple Mount Break Israel’s Unity Government?
Jerusalem Mayor Dismantles BBC Assertion That Israel Provoked Temple Mount Riots
Secret Plans Revealed: The Jordanian Prince & the Temple Mount
Of Vaccines, the Temple Mount and Palestinian Intransigence
Muslim Hurls Stones From Rooftop at Jews Visiting Temple Mount
Discrimination Against Jews on the Temple Mount Must End
Clarity on the Temple Mount
Saudis Say Temple Mount and Al Aqsa Not Important to Islam
Nearly 50,000 Jews ascended the Temple Mount in 5783
Arab Backlash Against Palestinian Provocations at the Temple Mount
“The Temple Mount Must Be a Top Priority for Israel”
What’s Really Happening at Jerusalem’s Holy Sites?
“Jerusalem Had No Mosques at the Time of Mohammed”
Temple Mount: Jews Ascend, Bow and Are Arrested
The Temple and Terrorism – A Dangerous Mix
UPDATE: Muslims Again Admit Jewish Temples Stood on Temple Mount
The Israeli Canary in the West’s Cultural Coal Mine
Ezekiel’s Temple – Metaphorical or Concrete? (Part 4)
Muslim Extremists Exploiting Corona Crisis in Israel
Ben Shapiro at Temple Mount: Jews Face Apartheid There
Jews Return to the Temple Mount
Will the King of Morocco Get a Seat on Jerusalem’s Temple Mount?
Open the Gates of the Temple Mount! Rabbis Urge Netanyahu
Priests Sacrifice Passover Lamb in Jerusalem
One Jew, and the World’s Furor
Tour the Temple Mount With Israel Today
Why are Israeli Children Taught the Western Wall is Judaism’s Holiest Site?
A Hidden Mountain, a Hidden River, and the Return of the King
Ben-Gvir Has Reenacted One of the Greatest Moments in Jewish History
Analysis: Temple Mount Tensions Threaten Israel
Straddling ‘The Place of His Throne’
Who Owns the Temple Mount?
From Hell to High Heaven Is Just a Stroll Away
Muslim Teacher Wants to See Jews Praying on Temple Mount
ANALYSIS: Temple Mount Crisis Shows Who’s Really in Charge in Israel
Muslims Quickly Bury Suspected Jewish History on Temple Mount
Riots in Jerusalem After Funeral of Muslim Injured on Temple Mount
Israeli NGO seeks prosecution of former Jerusalem mufti
Declaration of War! Palestinians Warn Jews Against Passover Sacrifice
Israel Today Membership
Monthly Membership
Yearly Membership
Save 18% Per Month.
Six Months Membership
Save 9% Per Month.
One response to “The Temple Mount Could Be Israel’s Symbol of Victory”
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.
Shalom Tom,
Well said, I remember as a youngster reading this about when Moshe Dyan said, uh, er, could I, should I? I was dumbstruck, later, I realized this was Elohim’ will, as you have aptly pointed out, should he have, really a big question that only HaShem had sorted out.
Regarding what Ben-Gvir did, will go down in His-Story as the moment the world stood still, after they got off the ground, they did nothing… Evil must be opposed and stopped in it’s tracks, full stop!
Toda Achi…